Technological
Most coolers use (frequency-controlled) 3-phase motors. Their speed is
controlled by the frequency of the board energy supply. Other equipment
(batteries etc.) supplied by the on-board grid, would then be strongly affected
as well. In this case a demand-control of ventilation would require a separate
frequency-variable energy supply, which is raises costs and complexity. This is
especially a problem for EMUs having a very complex on-board grid. Even if
separate inverter equipment is needed, LCC are still in favour of
demand-operated ventilation. However, in most cases manufacturers will not
implement a measure that raises the price of the vehicle even if it reduces
LCC.
Vibrational issues
Variable frequencies due to demand-controlled fans may cause vibrational
problems (resonant behaviour of train components). This problem has been
resolved according to SNCF. |